Thursday, February 27, 2020

Gender Roles in the Middle Ages and Renaissance


Women’s roles have been highly contested since the beginning of time.  Within the discussion of women’s roles come the questions of what constitutes a woman’s role, what will be used to enforce her position, and how much power she will be allotted in said role.  A priceless resource provided to historians in researching the evolution of women’s roles in the presence of art and women.  Not just the absence or presence of female artists through time, but art pieces that reflect a woman’s behavior, feelings, and lifestyle, provide a glimpse of the evolution of women’s roles throughout time.  Through fine art, contemporary historians can observe the differences between women’s roles, particularly in Europe, and particularly in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance.  Through the following pieces, artists, historians, and students alike may observe the evolution of the woman and the development of art and artists.


              From Hortus Deliciarum by Herrad of Landsberg

            Titled:  Philosophia et Septem Artes Liberales
(Philosophy and the Seven Liberal Arts)
Year:  After 1170  
During the Middle Ages, women were considered property, they were valued only as objects.  The worth of a woman derived from her status as wife, daughter, sister, mother, and so on.  Once married, "a woman had to obey her husband" (Guerilla Girls, 22), and she was to exist for his pleasure, never her own.  A woman in the Middle Ages was not entitled to her own identity, nonetheless her own property. There was a single exception to women’s inability to become educated and educate others and escape the sentence of an abusive marriage, the convent.  Choosing to commit their lives to the convent and pursue being a nun was the single greatest a choice a woman could make if she wanted to become educated and educate others.  Within the Middle Ages, various art pieces reflect a woman’s enlightenment being directly connected to her status as a nun.  The first piece, Hortus Deliciarum, a book created by Herrad of Landsberg, relays the transmission of learning shown through nuns in Germany.  What made this piece most special is that it is a book written by a woman that includes a dedication to all of the women who contributed to the making.  Herrad of Landsberg was able to pursue this due to her status as an abbess who was in a political and religious position to create pieces of art and literature for the education of others.     

From Liber Scivias
by Hildegard of Bingen 
Year:  1142-52
Similarly, Hildegard of Bingen’s piece, Scivas, is a staple of art and women within the Middle Ages as she enforces her own and her art’s legitimacy as direct contact with God.  Hildegard of Bingen created bodies of work on the basis that she was illustrating her religious experiences, which translated into her acceptance as a visionary.  Often during the era, "Churchmen who wrote about mystics tended to emphasize their inspiration and minimize their education" (Chadwick, 61),whereas Hildegard of Bingen used both her inspiration and her education to create her art and pursue religious female freedom.  During a period that women were not to read or write, nonetheless, create art or establish herself as an intellectual.  Due to Hildegard of Bingen’s religious experiences and revolutionary work, she became a politically active woman, creating work that revealed her conception of female otherness concerning Catholic male authority and circumventing the Church’s denial of power to women.  Due to her brilliance and her ability to dedicate her views to Catholicism, she received papal recognition for her art and her ideas.  Although most of the women who acquired power and produced art were nuns, which were not many, there existed a very few who pursued the arts.  Christine De Pizan, a widow who is considered to the first woman to have made her living as a writer, authored a work titled The Book of the City of Ladies, which crafted an argument against sexist scholars of the time.  A particular piece, The Bricklayers, depicts women as builders, instructors, thinkers, and are all empowered in the absence of men.  Through this work, and others, Christine De Pizan was able to establish herself as a courageous, outspoken intellectual and poet.  De Pizan was able to do the work of other women from that time, without having to attribute her brilliance to divine intervention as the nuns had done.

From The Book of the City of Ladies, The Bricklayers
 by Christine De Pizan
Year:  1405

The Renaissance continued the societal tradition of enforcing patriarchy and religion through art.  During the Renaissance, religion was of the utmost importance in Europe, and everything that was done socially, politically, and culturally, was done surrounding Catholicism.  Unfortunately for women of all statuses, "The Church's hierarchial organization reinforced the class distinctions in society; its patriarchal organization reinforced the class distinction in society; its patriarchal dogma included a full set of theories on the natural inferiority of women" (Chadwick, 44). 


Queen Ann of Austria
by Sofonisba Anguissola
Year:  1570
Furthermore, The Renaissance was a time of rebirth for Europe as the Middle Ages drifted slowly into oblivion.  Along with the rebirth of culture came the evolution of the artists’ role in society, along with women’s role in society.  With an increase of women appearing in art, came the increase of female artists.  Popular artists such as Artemisia Gentileschi, Sofonisba Anguissola, and Elisabetta Sirani paved the way for female artists and women in art.  Evolving in the Renaissance was the art of the portrait.  Women, with their roles as daughters, wives, and mothers, were painted to reflect their status.  The portrait became a way for men to parade their property through art.  Sofonisba Anguissola’s Queen Anne of Austriadepicts a woman’s beauty, which is equal to her worth, but also her husband’s wealth and status, which is most important.


Judith Slaying Holofernes
by Artemisia Gentileschi
Year:  1618
Along with the portrait depicted women similarly to how they had in the past, only with two new things, increasing power, and increasing evil.  The power depicted in pieces advertised from the Renaissance is “bottom power.”  Bottom power is power almost exclusively attributed to women as the power they receive from seducing powerful men.  Two pieces, Judith Slaying Holofernes by Artemisia Gentileschi and Portia Wounding Her Thigh by Elisabetta Sirani, incorporate the male gaze and the idea of bottom power.  In Judith Slaying Holofernes, Judith is a biblical hero, as she was able to save her city with her beauty.  The story of Judith slaying Holofernes is one of which she made herself appear beautiful enough to make Holofernes, the general of the army that seized her city, want to seduce her.  Once alone, Judith seized her opportunity to slay him, a story in which her beauty was the only reason she was given a chance to save her people.  Similarly, in Portia Wounding Her Thigh, by Elizabetta Sirani, a woman who's only power lies in her status as her husband's wife, must prove that she is worthy of being trusted by her husband.  Portia chooses to do the only thing which will gain respect, which is to reject her femininity.  While dressed beautifully to represent her husband's worth, Portia injures herself to signify her strength through physical pain. 
  

Portia Wounding Her Thigh
by Elizabetta Sirani
Year:  1664

With these artists and paintings being used as the foundation for women in art, female artists were enabled to flourish within the nineteenth century.  Along with the utilization of women in art came the utilization of other mediums for women to create their art. Although still difficult for women of lower classes, women of higher classes with access to art and supplies began representing women unapologetically.  As with all other histories, there was pushback against female artists that "asserted that famous women were miraculously endowed with the qualities that enabled them to succeed and thus could not serve as models for ordinary women" (Chadwick, 87).  One of the women used to represent intersectional artists, and unique mediums were Harriet Powers and the creation of her quilts.  Powers used the art form to tell stories and represent the African tradition which the medium stemmed; her work was later revived during the Second Wave of Feminism (1970s) to represent the women just like her, those existing in intersectionality.  

Pictorial Quilt 
by Harriet Powers
Year: 1895


Works Cited

Chadwick, Whitney. Women, Art, and Society. New York, N.Y.: Thames and Hudson, 1990. Print.


The Guerrilla Girls' Bedside Companion to the History of Western Art. New York: Penguin, 1998. Print.

    

No comments:

Post a Comment